Nick's dream began by introducing Nick and Eve as a couple. Eve was a blossoming singer who was managed by Nick. After a long time, he'd finally gotten her a chance to sing in New York on Broadway. Though Eve pledged to never leave Nick, all she gushed about was her singing career. Meanwhile, Nick was intrigued by the lonely April.

While Nick was beginning to be torn between Eve and April, another problem was that April was being wooed by Mike.

Eve was a huge success on the Great White Way. Eve and Nick began to celebrate this with a kiss...

...which was followed by a night of lovemaking. Unfortunately, Eve was already beginning to forget everything that Nick had done for her. While he thought about a future together, a spoiled Eve couldn't be bothered to think about anything other than her career. This seriously dismayed Nick, and his thoughts turned to April once again.

Later, Eve gave another successful performance. Scott Banning also managed to pop up in Nick's dream as the announcer at Eve's opening. He assured Nick that Eve was going places.

While Eve was singing, Nick took notice of a very beautiful and very lonesome April. Realizing that all Eve cared about was her career, Nick gave her a peck on the cheek and said, "So long." It was only as Nick was leaving with April that Eve realized what she'd lost.

Nick finally tells April how he feels about her. She confesses that he's attracted to him as well. Later on, they go ballroom dancing.

After a romantic dance, April and Nick finally kiss.

Later, Nick and April dance some more outside. They promise to commit to each other and to have no regrets. And thus ends Nick's dream, with April as his choice.